 |
|
By: Kirt Hill
The shareholders of Halliburton are trying to stop
state-sponsored terrorism, using the same economic leverage
that was effective against South African racism in the
1970's. Back then, shareholders used corporate resolutions
to stop companies from doing business in South Africa. The
tactic helped bring a peaceful end to an unpopular regime.
Today, shareholders are trying to stop companies from doing
business with "sponsors of terrorism".
Many Americans would be alarmed to learn that American
corporations are doing business with countries who are
linked to terrorism. U.S. law currently restricts trade by
American companies with states designated as "sponsors of
terrorism." Halliburton is an American company doing
business with two restricted nations - Iran and Syria. The
company circumvented the law by opening an office in Iran
under the name of Halliburton Products and Services Ltd,
its Cayman Islands subsidiary.
The U.S. government may not be able to stop the company
from using a subsidiary in this manner, but the company is
contending with an angry group of New York City Police and
Fire Department pension fund owners. On November 12, 2002,
the group submitted a shareowner resolution regarding
Halliburton's office in Iran. The resolution points out
that U.S. law restricts trade by American companies in
countries such as Iran, who are designated by the U.S.
State Department as "sponsors of terrorism." The company
believes that the operations of its subsidiaries in Iran
are in compliance with U.S. law. Halliburton may, in fact,
be operating legally in a technical sense. Some investors
are not satisfied.
According to William Thompson, the New York City
comptroller who oversees the $80 billion in pension funds
for all city workers, the oil revenue from the work the
company is doing may be underwriting or supporting
terrorism. In March of 2003, Halliburton agreed to fulfill
the terms of the resolution by establishing a Board
committee to review the potential financial and
reputational risks of its Iranian operations and submit a
report. Thompson subsequently withdrew the resolution.
However, Halliburton's report submitted in October of 2003
failed to address the concerns specified in the pension
funds' proposal. The report focused on financial and legal
risks, and said nothing about the reputational risk, or
potential public backlash against the company.
It's only a theory, but Halliburton may be reluctant to
address the issue due to the fact that the Vice-President
of the United States was in charge of the corporation when
the Cayman subsidiary was formed.
In any event, Thompson considered the report to be a breach
of Halliburton's promise to the Fire and Police pension
funds. In a letter to David J Lesar, CEO of Halliburton,
Thompson said "your counsel cannot excuse Halliburton's
complete failure to report on the reputational risks of
Halliburton's business activities in Iran by repeating, as
she does, your report's statement that Halliburton's
activities are technically within the letter of the law."
In closing he tells the company, "We continue to expect
Halliburton to honor its commitment, and to produce a full
and complete report that includes the Board's review of the
reputational risks of doing business with Iran."
On January 25, 2004 William Thompson made his case on the
CBS program "60 Minutes". The title of the segment was,
"Doing Business with the Enemy". 60 Minutes went to see the
Halliburton subsidiary in the Cayman Islands and found no
actual office there and no employees. When Halliburton
explained that the Cayman subsidiary is actually run out of
Dubai, 60 Minutes again went to see. In Dubai, they found
the subsidiary sharing office space with a division of its
U.S.-based parent company. This arrangement raised more
legal questions about the independence of the subsidiary.
If there is no agreement reached between now and the annual
meeting in May, there will be a proxy vote on the
resolution. When you own stock in a corporation you obtain
the right to vote on important matters concerning corporate
policies and governance. When you invest in a mutual fund
that holds stocks, you convey this important responsibility
to your mutual fund manager. Last year (2003) the SEC ruled
that mutual funds must disclose how they vote the proxies
in corporate-governance shareholder fights. If the
resolution comes to a vote in May, many large mutual fund
companies will be forced to vote either with the company,
or with the angry shareholders. We will be following this
story.
SUPPORTING STATEMENT from form 8-K:
According to the U.S. State Department, the Iranian
government has actively supported and funded terrorist
operations against innocent civilians outside its own
borders. These activities led to the imposition of
government sanctions that provide that virtually all trade
and investment activity with Iran by U.S. corporations, is
prohibited. We believe that Halliburton's use of its Cayman
Island subsidiary to establish operations in Tehran
violates the spirit, if not the letter of the law. It also
exposes the company to the prospect of negative publicity,
public protests, and a loss of consumer confidence, all of
which can have a negative impact on shareholder value.
The following is a list of the top mutual fund holders of
Halliburton reported as of 2003:
Growth Fund of America Inc
Van Kampen Comstock Fund
Fundamental Investors inc
Fidelity magellan fund inc
Lord Abbett Mid Cap Value Fund
Hartford Capital Appreciation Hls Fund, Inc
Putnam Fund For Growth and Income
Merrill Lynch Basic Value Fund
Vanguard 500 Index Fund
Washington Mutual Investors Fund
If you are interested in purchasing a share if Halliburton
(HAL)in order to vote on this resolution, click here, or
copy and paste this link to FOLIOfn into your browser
bar:
http://www.foliofn.com/wsjsp/lp/lp.fsp?id=CPVLRS00010304N
Please keep in mind that there is an ongoing dialogue
between the shareholders and the company, and the issue may
be resolved before it comes to a vote in May.
About the Author
Kirt Hill is a graduate of the University of Michigan. He founded his website, CapitaqlValues.com in 2004 to support socially responsible investing.
|
 |
|
Plan Your Getaway To The US Virgin Islands St Johns
The three islands and sixty-odd cays that comprise the US Virgin Islands are proud of their magnificent seashores, terrific food and accommodation and the abundance of tourist based activities. St. John U.S. Virgin Islands itself is a natural wonder of aquatic elements, glittering bays, tropical for
Cayman Islands – Pristine Sea Sides With Modern Amenities
Are you looking for a vacation by idyllic seashores? The Cayman Islands of the Caribbean should be the perfect choice. The combined magic of the Grand Cayman, the Little Cayman and the Cayman Brac are sure to work. Best of all, these havens of natural beauty are equipped with excellent facilities fo
Ecuador Travel – Quito Volcanoes Galapagos Island
Located in the Andeas, Ecuador is a land of intrigue for travelers. Travel to Ecuador and you can trek the Amazon, climb volcanoes, or loaf on beautiful beaches. Perhaps the biggest reason to travel to Ecuador is a visit to the famous Galapagos Islands. Regardless of your preference, the following a
Hedge Fund 101 Make Money With Hedge Funds
Investors are always looking for the best investments that will yield the most profit. Any investor who can afford the extra cost should consider investing in Hedge Funds. Hedge Funds were started in 1949 by Alfred Winslow Jones, who pioneered non-traditional investment strategies. Jones innovated t
Medas Islands And Their Amazing Marine Life
The Medas Islands are located at the Mediterranean Sea, more specifically in Spain, and are one of that region's diving spots where the most wide and beautiful marine life can be observed. This diving area concentrates an important amount of different fish species and marine creatures in general, an
Diving In The Ustica Islands
Although it is not commonly known as a diving destination, Sicily, in Italy, does offer a great diving area which is the Ustica Islands. The Ustica Islands is a very beautiful area for divers to visit, since they could not only practice their sport and meet incredible underwater sceneries but also e
Dangerous Reef And Its Sharks
Dangerous Reef is a famous Western Australia dive destination due to the sharks which can be observed in it. Divers who enjoy intense and risky sports usually choose this Australian area as their diving destination. Due to the real danger that these sharks imply, it is important for visitors and div
Looking For A Vacation In Paradise Try A Bahamas Vacation
Plan your next vacation where most people call paradise...the Bahamas Islands. Choose from the many islands such as Grand Bahama Island, Nassau, Paradise Island, Abaco and Eleuthera. The Bahamas is an archipelago of over 700 islands. Find a perfect Bahamas vacation rental and enjoy all that a Bahama
Continuing Change In The Offshore World
The offshore financial centres have been forced in recent years to review almost every aspect of the ways in which they operate in response to the international anti- money laundering laws and initiatives by major economies such as the E.U. and the U.S.A. to increase co-operation in the areas of pre
Grand Cayman After The Hurricane Season
One of the ports visited on our recent Royal Caribbean cruise was Grand Cayman. This was an eagerly awaited port since I've been there before but wanted to take my girlfriend scuba diving there. We were worried that we might miss this port since the Caymans were hit pretty hard by the hurricanes an
Domain Registries From Around The World
Domain registries from around the world. By Clare Lawrence 29th September 2003 Clare is the CEO of Discount Domains Ltd a leading UK Domain name registration service.Do you sometimes come across exotic looking TLD's? Ever wondered which domain name is from where? I created the following table out of
Navigating The Global Internet
If you have clients or customers in other countries and work on the Internet, here’s a primer to help you decipher the URLs and emails you’ll be receiving.First of all, extensions. The most common are .com, for commercial sites; .edu or .ac for educational sites; .gov for government sites; and .org
Halliburton Under Fire For Operations In Iran
The shareholders of Halliburton are trying to stopstate-sponsored terrorism, using the same economic leveragethat was effective against South African racism in the1970's. Back then, shareholders used corporate resolutionsto stop companies from doing business in South Africa. Thetactic helped bring a
For A Romantic Beginning
-FOR A ROMANTIC BEGINNING-IF YOU’RE UNDECIDED ON PLANS FOR YOUR WEDDING AND/OR HONEYMOON, JUST CONSIDER THE FOLLOWING IDEAS:SANDALS AND BEACHES“LOVE IS ALL YOU NEED”WeddingMoonsFree for couples who stay five nights or longer. Your Sandals complimentary WeddingMoon’s package includes:Preparation of d
|
|
|
